Compare

The Submagic alternative for long podcasts and streams (2026)

Submagic is known for caption styling. It was built for videos that are already short, so people cutting long podcasts often find its length caps, or the add-on needed for long videos, get in the way.

Our bias: we make Shorts by Slice. Compared from published pricing, limits, features and user reviews, checked 30 September 2026. We did not test Submagic hands-on, and where it is the better choice we say so.

Shorts by Slice turns a long podcast or stream into captioned vertical clips. $14.99 a month. Your first video (we search the first hour) and first 2 clips are free, no card. After that, buy clips one at a time or take the plan, which you can cancel any time.

Try it free →

Which is better, Submagic or Slice?

It depends. Submagic is best for styling captions, b-roll and zooms on videos that are already short, in almost any language. Shorts by Slice (ours) is best for podcasters and clippers who cut long episodes and streams, video or audio-only, into lots of clips and export them in one go. As of October 2026, Slice is $14.99 a month. Submagic started at $19/month, or $12/month billed yearly when we checked on 30 September 2026.

Slice vs Submagic

Shorts by SliceSubmagic
Price$14.99/month or $149/year$19 / $39 / $69 a month, or $12 / $23 / $41 billed yearly; Magic Clips +$19/month
What the entry plan getsEverything: 6 hours of video and 100 clips a month, no watermarkStarter: 15 videos a month, up to 2 minutes each, 1080p
Longest video3 hours and 4.5GB (MP4, MOV or WebM)2 min (Starter), 5 min (Pro), 30 min (Business); Magic Clips limit not stated
Monthly limitUp to 6 hours of video and 100 clips a month15, 40 or 100 videos; Magic Clips 10 uploads
WatermarkNeverNone, on any tier
Link importUpload only for now: MP4, MOV or WebM, up to 4.5GBMagic Clips takes YouTube links
PostingNo: you download and postNot covered in our check
Captions and languagesCaptions in the speaker's language; fonts cover Latin scripts and Hebrew123 languages, strong styling, auto-zoom, b-roll
ReviewsNo third-party ratings to report yetTrustpilot 4.5 (842), G2 4.6 (85), Capterra 5.0 (1), Product Hunt 4.4 (30)

Submagic’s figures from its pricing page and review sites, 30 September 2026. Prices in US dollars.

Choose Submagic if…

  • Your videos are already short and you want styled captions, zooms and b-roll on them.
  • You caption in one of its 123 languages that Slice's fonts do not cover.
  • You want automatic b-roll and silence removal in the same tool.

Choose Slice if…

  • You start from a long episode. Slice takes up to 3 hours on its one plan; on Submagic, clipping a long video is the Magic Clips add-on, $19 a month for 10 uploads, on top of a plan.
  • You make many clips from each episode and want to export them together.
  • You want one price that covers finding, editing and exporting clips.
  • You want clips cut the way an editor would cut them. Slice is built by video editors: every clip starts and ends where the thought does, and on a two-person video the picture switches 0.17s before the next voice, close to the timing we measured in professional podcasts.

Submagic, in short

Best for styling captions, b-roll and zooms on videos that are already short, in almost any language.

Pricing, in plain words

  • Starter: $19 a month, or $12 a month billed yearly. 15 videos a month, each up to 2 minutes, 1080p at 30fps.
  • Pro: $39 a month, or $23 a month billed yearly. 40 videos, up to 5 minutes each, b-roll, 3 users.
  • Business: $69 a month, or $41 a month billed yearly. 100 videos, up to 30 minutes each, 4K at 60fps.
  • Magic Clips, which turns a long video into clips, is a paid add-on: $19 a month for 10 uploads. It takes YouTube links and makes "20+" clips.
  • No watermark on any tier. No free plan, but you can try it without a card.
Submagic's pricing page as it appeared on 30 September 2026
Submagic's pricing page, 30 September 2026 Tap to enlarge.

What Submagic’s reviewers say

SiteRatingReviews
Trustpilot4.5 / 5842
G24.6 / 585
Capterra5.0 / 51
Product Hunt4.4 / 530

Praise: Fast caption styling; Accurate captions; Support often praised.

Recurring complaints: Surprise renewals or refunds (12 of 25); Support (8 of 25); Failed exports (6 of 25); Pricing confusion (4 of 25).

Source: Trustpilot 1-2 star reviews, 25 reviews. A sample, not every review. Read them on Trustpilot.

“changing the features… every few months”A reviewer on Product Hunt

Slice, in short

Best for podcasters and clippers who cut long episodes and streams, video or audio-only, into lots of clips and export them in one go.

$14.99 a month or $149 a year. Your first video (we search the first hour) and first 2 clips are free, no card. It does not post, schedule or add b-roll for you. Upload the file (MP4, MOV or WebM, up to 4.5GB).

Three clips ticked on the Slice clips page with an "Export these 3" button above them
Batch export in Slice: tick the clips, then "Export these 3", 30 September 2026 Tap to enlarge.
The Shorts by Slice editor with a vertical clip showing the hook title "The starving artist is a load of crap" over the speaker
A clip in Slice's editor with its hook title on, 30 September 2026 Tap to enlarge.

Slice on a real episode, start to finish

We did not run Submagic, so we will not guess how it does. Here is what Slice did with a real one. The episode is LinuxGameCast Weekly 430, a three-host video podcast, 1:21:55 long, 1280×720, 531MB, published by LinuxGameCast LLP under CC BY-SA 4.0. We ran it through Slice on 2 October 2026 and read the times back from our own database afterwards.

  • Upload of the 531MB file: about two minutes.
  • Three and a half minutes after the upload finished, Slice listed four moments. Most of that was the transcript; the search itself took 39 seconds.
  • No moment was one unbroken stretch. “The lady with the magic calligraphy books” runs 1:07, joined from 17 passages between 1:20 and 4:05; “I spent two months fighting Netflix over a copyright claim” runs 1:11, from 6 passages.
  • We picked two. Both were finished 4 minutes later: 1080×1920 MP4s at 30 frames a second: 1:08 and 1:11 long, 70MB and 56MB.
Four suggested clips from an 82-minute episode on the Slice website: The lady with the magic calligraphy books (1m 7s), I spent two months fighting Netflix over a copyright claim (1m 11s), Twitch and YouTube are not your friends (34s) and A $4 Android game slapped on Steam (51s), each with a row of marks showing where it comes from in the episode and a Use this clip button.
What Slice found in LinuxGameCast Weekly 430, an 82-minute episode: four moments, listed 39 seconds after the transcript was ready. The marks on each row show where its passages sit in the episode. Tap to enlarge.

What came out wrong

  • The framing. The episode is three webcams side by side under the show’s logo. Slice kept the middle camera, cut the logo to “AST 430”, and a line of stream chat shows in the first clip.
  • The joins. One join dropped a word; another left a stray “have.” between two sentences.
  • The language. The show swears, and the third moment opens on it, so we skipped that one.
Left: the original 16:9 frame of the stream, three webcams side by side under a LINUXGAMECAST 430 logo, with chat alerts along the bottom. Right: the vertical clip made from it, showing only the middle webcam, with the logo cut to "AST 430".
Left, the original 1280×720 stream layout: three webcams and a chat bar. Right, the vertical clip: Slice kept the middle camera and cut the logo in half. Tap to enlarge.

Each of those is a fix in the editor before posting. The full run, with both clips frame by frame, is in Can ChatGPT make clips from my video?.

Or do it inside ChatGPT

If you already work in ChatGPT, you don’t have to open another app. Add Slice to ChatGPT once, attach the video in a chat and type “@Slice turn this video into short clips”. Slice lists the moments it found with their lengths and opening lines; reply with the numbers you want and you get download links for vertical clips with captions and a hook title. Clips need a Slice plan (your first 2 clips on the website are free).

Can ChatGPT make clips from my video? has a real run from upload to finished files. The full steps are in how to make podcast clips with ChatGPT, and adding Slice takes a couple of minutes with the setup guide.

Questions

Can Submagic clip a full podcast episode?

Yes, with Magic Clips, a paid add-on at $19 a month for 10 uploads that accepts YouTube links. Without it, each plan caps the video length: 2 minutes on Starter, 5 on Pro, 30 on Business. Checked 30 September 2026.

Does Submagic watermark?

No, on any tier. Neither does Slice.

Does Slice have b-roll like Submagic?

Partly. Since October 2026 you can put b-roll on a Slice clip’s timeline yourself: your own pictures and videos, or free stock pictures and videos from Pixabay that you search in the editor. Slice does not add b-roll for you. If you want it added for you, Submagic (Pro and up) or OpusClip have that.

What do people complain about with Submagic?

In 25 Trustpilot 1-2 star reviews, twelve mention surprise renewals or refunds, eight support, six failed exports and four pricing confusion. Its overall Trustpilot score is 4.5 from 842 reviews, and many reviewers praise its support.

How was this compared?

Compared from published pricing, limits, features and user reviews, checked 30 September 2026. Submagic's figures are from its own pricing page, help centre and review pages. We did not test Submagic hands-on. We make Slice.

Get The Cut

What's working in short-form video, one short email every Tuesday.

Unsubscribe any time. Privacy

More comparisons

All comparisons, in one list.

Try Shorts by Slice on your next episode. If Submagic fits you better, use it.

Put the last clip you posted through it.

Your first video (we search the first hour) and first 2 clips are free, no card. After that, buy clips one at a time or take the plan, which you can cancel any time.